Top Ten Tuesdays was created by The Broke and Bookish, but is now hosted weekly by That Artsy Reader Girl and anyone is free to participate! This week’s topic is page to books too precious to touch. I don’t collect books for personal reasons, and my library is not super big because I like having a small personal collection. The only books I hold dearly are the books I have signed by my favorite author, but I still lend them out. All this being said, I don’t own any books I wouldn’t let anyone touch. I want to own books so that my children can read them and other people can lend them out (though I would appreciate some courtesy when my friends and family read them), so this topic is a little moot for me. So instead of books, I’m going with characters that are too precious to touch
I think there’s a lot of characters that are so amazing, but I also am really protective of some characters because people tend to judge them too harshly because they think they’re “not serious enough” or their behavior “is stupid”. So I definitely have characters I like people to think a little more critically about, and not just take at face value. As readers and people two tend to think deeply about their characters, I think we’re all guilty of taking attacks at our favorite characters personally. And on the other end of the spectrum, are equally as guilty of judging someone else’s favorite too quickly. So let me know if you have any characters like that, I’m always looking for more unique perspectives on characters that add depth. Alright, let’s go!
- Sansa Stark from Game of Thrones (the TV show)
SPOILERS FOR THE ENTIRE SERIES (highlight to read—it’s in white text) BUTTTTTTT… I flipping love Sansa. She’s the first person on this list just because I just finished the entire series (I can finally get back on the Internet HUZZAH). She is such a strong character, and I think she’s also a poster child for characters who are simplified and judged at face value—this all in combination with sexism too. Particularly in the early seasons. I mean yes, she wants to be queen and blindly follows and is too trusting, but I think EVERYONE forgets or ignores the fact that she was a CHILD at this time. She doesn’t have to be anyone, and even if she just wants to be queen everyone just dumps on her because “oh she’s a silly little girl, and is so stupid”. I get so fired up when people blame Sansa for what happened to her and how she reacted. PROTECT SANSA QUEEN OF THE NORTH FOREVER. - Harry Potter from The Order of the Pheonix by J.K. Rowling
I feel really strongly about this, and I apologize because I’m sure I’ve included or talked about Harry Potter in the fifth book on this blog very recently. But it really kind of pushes my buttons when people complain about him being “whiney” in the 5th book. He’s a little… hard to understand. But considering the events at the end of the 4th book (and the 5th picks up right after the 4th ends), it’s totally understandable. Harry is clearly suffering from PTSD and/or depression but people just complain that he’s angsty and being a teenager… Um no he was just held hostage and watched a friend of his be murdered. Of course his behavior isn’t going to be up to our A+ standards. I just really think people should think about that before complaining that he’s annoying. - Lara Jean from To All The Boys I’ve Loved Before
People always complain about Lara Jean being naive and so young. But I don’t see that as a bad thing. I mean she’s a little naive in some ways, but also very wise in a lot of ways. The writing of the book reflects and suggests what we read is exactly how Lara Jean thinks, and I love that about the book. There’s a a kind of humble joy in Lara Jean that I think is void of so many characters. Lara Jean is also one of subtle and quiet strength, she’s quite resilient and though people don’t think of this book as feminist, I think Lara Jean is a great example of feminism, especially because she has always respected herself and done what’s best for her. She has a healthy amount of skepticism, but is also willing to forgive people. Overall she’s much more complex than a “silly girl who just likes to bake”. - Lydia Bennet from Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen
So many people love to hate Lydia Bennet (I know I use to be one of them). I was chatting with my good friend Jessica a few weeks ago about Lydia and she totally changed my perspective on Lydia Bennet. I detailed it a lot in a discussion post, but it kind of boils down to the fact that we on some level believe Lydia got what she deserved when she ended up with Wickham, which is absolutely not true. It also leads back to new age feminism. Like we give more slack to girls and women who are strong and independent; who pull themselves out of their own situations and “earn the respect of the men and equality they deserve.” But that’s the thing with feminism; you don’t have to do anything or be anything to deserve respect and equality. You just automatically get it because you’re a human, and Lydia deserves more of that.
What a sweet post, I love this. Also, QUEEN OF THE NORTH!!!! I cried so hard, no shame! I get tired of people complaining about young people being young LOL Like what even? It makes no sense so I feel you on the Lara Jean thing!
LikeLike
Ah thank you so much Melanie!! And YES!!! I was actually really happy with how GOT ended!! It was very satisfying for me, though I mean Sansa would have made a killer (no pun intended) Queen of Westeros.
LikeLike
I agree with you so much about Harry Potter from the fifth book. It was awful how many people made him out to be a fool when he was telling the truth the entire time and only a select few believed him.
LikeLike
YES! Absolutely! There’s so much to unpack in HP5, but it’s just written off as the “middle angsty book”. *rolls eyes*
LikeLike
It is definitely angsty but the reasons are 100% justifiable. And there really is a lot to unpack in not only HP5 but HP6 and HP7 as well.
LikeLike
So true! I like how smooth the maturing of the series is. She did such a good job bridging that MGxYA gap!
LikeLike
Lydia was a foolish girl, but she was encouraged in her foolishness. And she did deserve someone better than Wickham.
LikeLike
Absolutely!! I’ve totally come to see Lydia in a new light—whereas before I had kind of only given Mary the benefit of the doubt.
LikeLike
What a fun take on the topic! Very unique.
LikeLike
Thank you!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Fun twist on the topic! I love your list, and completely agree that Lydia deserved better — better than Wickham, better support than she was given, just better everything. She alone wasn’t to blame for her foolishness.
And sorry… but I’m going to have to disagree about Harry in book 5. I don’t mind him acting like a teenager, but I really didn’t like him in that book. I haven’t read it recently enough to give specifics, so I won’t try. It’s the only book I have an issue with his characterization, though. 🙂
LikeLike
I love how you included Lydia Bennet on this list! I’ll definitely pay more attention to her character next time I reread the book!
Also, have you ever seen the Lizzie Bennet Diaries? It’s a modern day P&P retelling told through the form of Elizabeth’s “Lizzie’s” vlog entries. It’s on Youtube and though a little weird, it’s super good and addicting! In LBD they give Lydia a lot more depth and even an offshoot Youtube channel with her own vlog entries that really make you empathize with her. I think you might like it! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve heard so much about the Lizzie Bennet Diaries and I’m slowly working my way through them!! That’s so cool they included Lydia and gave her an off shoot. I’ll definitely have to check it out!
LikeLike
I get really protective of some characters too. I’ve never watched Game of Thrones, but I feel like I know some of the characters because of all the Twitter discourse over the years and Sansa is one that I like. I’m so protective of Lara Jean and I think part of it is that I see so much of my younger self in her, it’s kind of like people are insulting me. How dare. Love your list!
LikeLike
One of my fave and most memorable moments in HP is in HP5, when Harry had a breakdown at Dumbledore’s office and shouted that if this is what it was to be human, then he doesn’t want to be human (or something like that I’m going by memory sorry). But I liked it because it was just so raw. That really got me.
LikeLike
That is SUCH an emotional scene! I totally cried when Sirius died in the 5th book; so emotional and then Harry just feels so betrayed. I’m so sad. I wanted them to live together so badly. And Harry’s pain was written so well and that scene had such unguarded emotion in it.
LikeLiked by 1 person